Políticas

Revista Estrategia Organizacional is an open-access scientific journal. All its content is made available online immediately and free of charge, without embargo periods or subscription requirements.

The journal promotes open access to scientific knowledge in order to support its dissemination, use, exchange and circulation among researchers, institutions and society.

Readers may access, read, download, share and reuse published content in accordance with the conditions established by the applicable licence.

Publication Licence

Articles published by Revista Estrategia Organizacional are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International licence (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

This licence allows published content to be shared and adapted, provided that appropriate credit is given to the authors and the original source, the material is not used for commercial purposes, and any derivative works are distributed under the same licence.

The applicable licence is identified in the published content and establishes the conditions governing its use and reuse.

Copyright

Authors retain copyright in their works, including their moral rights and the rights necessary to reuse and disseminate their work in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons licence applied by the journal.

By agreeing to publication, authors grant the Universidad Nacional Abierta y a Distancia (UNAD) and Revista Estrategia Organizacional the necessary authorisation to first publish the article and to reproduce, distribute, publicly communicate, preserve and store it, incorporate it into scientific information systems, and disseminate it through the media and platforms necessary to ensure its accessibility, visibility and preservation.

This authorisation does not limit recognition of authorship or prevent authors from subsequently reusing, depositing or disseminating their work in accordance with the conditions established by the publication licence.

Authors warrant that they hold the necessary rights and permissions for the content submitted and that its publication does not infringe the intellectual property rights of third parties.

Self-Archiving and Repository Deposit

Revista Estrategia Organizacional permits authors to self-archive and deposit the journal’s published version of the article (Version of Record) immediately after publication, without an embargo period.

Authors may deposit this version in institutional or subject repositories, academic websites, academic profiles and other non-commercial scholarly dissemination systems.

The deposited version must retain the article’s bibliographic information, acknowledge its original publication in Revista Estrategia Organizacional, and include the DOI or permanent link to the version published on the journal’s official website.

This policy is intended to support the preservation, discoverability, accessibility and circulation of the scientific research published by the journal.

Open Access Without Charges for Authors or Readers

The open-access model of Revista Estrategia Organizacional does not involve Article Processing Charges (APCs), submission fees, peer-review fees, editorial processing fees or publication charges.

Access to and downloading of published articles are also free of charge for readers.

The costs associated with editorial management, publication and dissemination are institutionally supported by the Universidad Nacional Abierta y a Distancia (UNAD), in accordance with the journal’s Publication Charges and Funding Policy.

Third-Party Material

Authors are responsible for obtaining, where applicable, the necessary permissions to reproduce figures, tables, photographs, instruments, images, excerpts or other copyright-protected material belonging to third parties.

Third-party material that is not covered by the article’s general licence must be appropriately identified and remain subject to its applicable copyright or licensing conditions.

Specific requirements are set out in the journal’s Third-Party Material Policy.

Dissemination and Interoperability of Open-Access Content

Revista Estrategia Organizacional promotes the circulation, discoverability and interoperability of its content and metadata through repositories, indexing and abstracting services, discovery services, persistent identifiers and other scholarly communication infrastructures used by the journal.

The distribution of metadata and content is carried out in accordance with the journal’s open-access, copyright and licensing conditions.

Relationship with Other Editorial Policies

Requirements concerning originality, authorship and contributions, conflicts of interest, research integrity, research ethics, the use of artificial intelligence, research misconduct and other aspects of editorial responsibility are addressed in the Code of Ethics and Good Practice and in the specific policies of Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

General Principles

Revista Estrategia Organizacional is committed to originality, integrity, and the appropriate attribution of sources in all manuscripts submitted for consideration.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted works are original; that ideas, data, texts, methods, results, images, and other materials derived from other sources are properly acknowledged and cited; and that any reuse of their own previously published work is transparent and appropriately referenced where applicable.

The journal considers plagiarism, the appropriation of ideas or content belonging to others without attribution, the substantial unacknowledged reproduction of texts, and the inappropriate or undisclosed reuse of content previously published by the authors themselves to be incompatible with good scientific publishing practices.

Similarity Detection

As part of the editorial evaluation process, manuscripts submitted to Revista Estrategia Organizacional are analysed using Turnitin as a tool for detecting textual similarity.

The similarity report generated by Turnitin constitutes a supporting tool for editorial assessment and does not, in itself, determine the existence of plagiarism.

Revista Estrategia Organizacional does not consider the overall similarity percentage to be the sole or automatic criterion for accepting or rejecting a manuscript. Results are examined by the editorial team, taking into account the nature, extent, concentration, source, and context of the identified similarities.

During this assessment, consideration is given, among other elements, to properly identified direct quotations, bibliographic references, commonly used technical expressions, methodological descriptions, works previously published by the authors themselves, and other similarities that may be legitimately justified.

Assessment of Potential Cases of Plagiarism

When analysis using Turnitin or editorial assessment identifies similarities that may constitute plagiarism, inappropriate reuse of content, or insufficient attribution, the journal will evaluate the case before making a decision.

Depending on the nature, extent, and severity of the situation, the editorial team may:

a) request clarification or additional documentation from the authors;
b) require the correction of citations, references, attributions, or inappropriate paraphrasing;
c) request substantial revisions to the manuscript before continuing the editorial process;
d) reject the manuscript when the evidence establishes plagiarism, misappropriation, substantial duplication, or another breach of research integrity; or
e) initiate the procedure established in the Misconduct Policy where there are indications of a possible serious breach.

Editorial decisions will be based on an assessment of the available evidence and not exclusively on the similarity percentage generated by Turnitin.

Reuse of Authors’ Own Work

The reuse of content previously published by the same authors will be assessed according to its extent, nature, transparency, relevance to the new work, and appropriate reference to the original publication.

Authors must identify and cite their previous works when reusing information, arguments, data, methods, or other content requiring attribution.

Substantial reuse of a previous publication without appropriate identification or justification may be considered redundant or duplicate publication and will be assessed in accordance with the journal’s research integrity policies.

Plagiarism Detected During the Editorial Process

When a case of plagiarism is confirmed prior to publication, Revista Estrategia Organizacional may reject the manuscript and close the editorial process.

Where justified by the severity or circumstances of the case, it may be referred to the Editorial Committee or the appropriate body for assessment in accordance with the journal’s Code of Ethics and Good Practices and Misconduct Policy.

Authors will be informed of the decision and the reasons supporting it.

Plagiarism Identified After Publication

Allegations or evidence of possible plagiarism received after publication will be assessed regardless of the time elapsed since the article was published.

Revista Estrategia Organizacional will analyse the nature and extent of the affected material, the original sources, the attribution provided, the authors’ explanations, and the potential consequences for the integrity of the article and the scholarly record.

Confirmation of plagiarism does not automatically result in the removal of the article from the journal’s website.

Depending on the severity and extent of the case, the journal may publish a correction, an expression of concern, a retraction, or another appropriate editorial notice, while preserving the identification and traceability of the scholarly record.

In cases of substantial plagiarism or other serious breaches of integrity, the journal may consider retracting the article and, where appropriate, communicating the matter to relevant institutions, publications, or other parties.

Post-publication actions will be undertaken in coordination with the journal’s Complaints and Corrections Policy and Misconduct Policy.

Allegations and Assessment Procedure

Communications concerning potential cases of plagiarism will be examined confidentially, in a documented and impartial manner.

The journal will seek to obtain and preserve the necessary evidence, provide authors with an opportunity to respond to the issues raised, and adopt measures proportionate to the nature and severity of the case.

Where appropriate, Revista Estrategia Organizacional may refer to the principles, procedures, and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) when assessing and managing potential cases of plagiarism and other breaches of publication integrity.

Relationship with Other Editorial Policies

This policy should be interpreted in conjunction with the Code of Ethics and Good Practices, the Misconduct Policy, the Complaints and Corrections Policy, and the other provisions concerning research integrity adopted by Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Digital archives preservation policy

Long-Term Preservation and Availability

The digital preservation of published scholarly content is an essential component in ensuring the continuity of the scholarly record of Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

For this purpose, institutional and technological mechanisms are maintained to preserve published articles, journal issues, associated files and metadata, reduce the risk of information loss, and support their long-term availability and recovery.

Institutional Infrastructure

Digital content is managed and stored through the technological infrastructure of the Digital Periodicals Library of the Universidad Nacional Abierta y a Distancia (UNAD), using Open Journal Systems (OJS) as the platform for editorial management, publication and maintenance of the journal’s digital archive.

This infrastructure hosts published issues, articles, associated files and metadata that constitute the journal’s digital scholarly record.

Preservation through PKP Preservation Network

As an additional distributed preservation mechanism, published content is deposited through the PKP Preservation Network (PKP PN), a service developed by the Public Knowledge Project (PKP) for journals managed using Open Journal Systems.

PKP PN uses a distributed infrastructure based on LOCKSS (Lots of Copies Keep Stuff Safe) technology, through which copies of deposited content are preserved across the network.

This mechanism complements institutional storage and helps reduce dependence on a single technological infrastructure, supporting the long-term recovery and availability of published scholarly content in the event of technical incidents, migrations or changes to the platforms used.

The operation and appropriate configuration of these mechanisms form part of the management and maintenance processes of the institutional technological infrastructure.

Continuity of the Scholarly Record

Preservation mechanisms are intended to ensure that published content remains available, identifiable and recoverable over time.

In accordance with the technical characteristics of the systems used, preservation encompasses published content and its associated metadata, contributing to the continuity and traceability of the scholarly record.

Corrections, retractions and other post-publication actions are managed in a manner that preserves the relationship between the originally published article and any subsequent amendments or editorial notices, in accordance with the editorial policies of Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Historical Archive

Issues published since the establishment of Revista Estrategia Organizacional remain available through its historical archive, which provides a public record of the journal’s editorial history and continuity.

The preservation and accessibility of this archive ensure the continued availability of published research and facilitate its long-term consultation, retrieval and use.

Interoperability

Preservation mechanisms are complemented by interoperability tools designed to facilitate the identification, retrieval and circulation of metadata associated with published content.

For this purpose, the journal uses the Open Archives Initiative Protocol for Metadata Harvesting (OAI-PMH), which enables the automated harvesting of metadata by repositories, digital libraries, discovery services, scholarly information systems and other compatible academic infrastructures.

The OAI-PMH service of Revista Estrategia Organizacional is available at:

https://hemeroteca.unad.edu.co/index.php/revista-estrategica-organizacio/oai

OAI-PMH serves an interoperability and metadata dissemination function and therefore complements, but does not replace, the journal’s dedicated digital preservation mechanisms.

Review and Updating

Preservation mechanisms may be updated in response to developments in the technological infrastructure of the Universidad Nacional Abierta y a Distancia, the functionalities available through Open Journal Systems, the preservation services implemented and evolving good practices in digital scholarly publishing.

Public information concerning digital preservation should reflect the mechanisms that are effectively implemented and operational, thereby supporting the transparency and verifiability of the journal’s strategy for preserving the scholarly record.

Research Articles

Revista Estrategia Organizacional publishes original research articles that fall within its focus and scope and contribute to the development, analysis and application of management strategies across different organisational contexts and fields of knowledge.

Published manuscripts must present an original and clearly identifiable scholarly contribution, supported by a rigorous research process and a methodology appropriate to the nature of the research problem.

Articles should clearly identify the research problem, purpose, objectives or research questions; present the relevant theoretical or conceptual foundations; describe the methodology employed; report and analyse the results or findings; and set out the main conclusions, implications, limitations and contributions of the study.

The internal structure of the manuscript may be adapted to the methodological and epistemological characteristics of the research. However, sufficient information must be provided to enable readers to understand how the study was conducted, how the evidence was obtained and analysed, and how the work contributes to existing knowledge.

Particular consideration will be given to studies that provide new findings, perspectives, models, methods or scientific evidence and contribute to advancing knowledge of management strategies and the fields covered by the journal’s scope.

Originality and Scholarly Contribution

Manuscripts must explicitly identify their original contribution to knowledge and demonstrate its relationship to the existing scholarly literature.

The presentation of background information and the review of relevant literature are important components of a research article but do not replace the requirement to provide an original scholarly contribution derived from a methodologically sound research process.

Manuscripts that are exclusively descriptive, academic works without a clearly identifiable scholarly contribution, or literature reviews limited to compiling or summarising existing publications will not be considered for publication.

Thematic Issues and Special Sections

Revista Estrategia Organizacional may publish thematic issues or special sections devoted to research topics of particular relevance to its focus and scope.

Articles published within thematic issues or special sections must meet the same standards of originality, scientific rigour, editorial integrity and peer review as articles published in regular issues.

The involvement of guest editors or publication within a thematic issue does not alter the journal’s evaluation criteria or scientific requirements.

Evaluation of Articles

All research articles are subject to the editorial assessment and peer-review procedures established by Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Acceptance is based on the manuscript’s alignment with the journal’s focus and scope, the originality and relevance of its contribution, methodological rigour, quality of analysis and compliance with the journal’s editorial policies.

Specific requirements concerning titles, abstracts, keywords, manuscript length and structure, references, supplementary files and other aspects of manuscript preparation and submission are established in the Author Guidelines available in the Submissions section.

Immediate and Free Access

All content published by Revista Estrategia Organizacional is made immediately and freely available online.

Access to published articles does not require subscription, registration or payment by readers, and no embargo period is applied to published content.

This model facilitates access to and circulation of research findings among the scientific community, institutions, students, professionals and other interested readers, supporting the exchange and dissemination of scholarly knowledge.

Access, Downloading and Reuse

Users may read, access, download and share published articles in accordance with the terms of the licence applicable to the journal’s content.

Articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International licence (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0), which permits users to share and adapt the content provided that appropriate credit is given to the authors and the original source, the material is not used for commercial purposes, and any derivative works are distributed under the same licence.

The full terms of the licence are available at:

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Relationship with the Open Access Policy

Conditions concerning copyright, publication licensing, reuse, self-archiving, repository deposit and third-party material are set out in the Open Access and Copyright Policy of Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Revista Estrategia Organizacional has established procedures for addressing complaints and appeals related to the editorial process and for correcting the scholarly record when necessary following publication.

These procedures are guided by the principles of integrity, transparency, impartiality and traceability established in the journal’s editorial policies and take into account the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Complaints about the Editorial Process

Authors, reviewers and other participants in the editorial process may submit complaints concerning the editorial handling of a manuscript, the peer-review process, potential breaches of editorial policies or other matters related to the publication process.

Complaints should be appropriately substantiated and, where applicable, accompanied by the information or evidence required for their assessment.

Requests should be submitted to the journal’s official email address, revista.ecacen@unad.edu.co, clearly identifying the manuscript or article concerned and explaining the reasons for the complaint.

The journal will assess complaints confidentially, impartially and in a documented manner, seeking to ensure that individuals directly involved in the matter concerned are not solely responsible for resolving the complaint.

Appeals against Editorial Decisions

Authors may request reconsideration of an editorial decision when they believe that there are sufficient scientific, methodological or procedural grounds to do so.

The appeal must clearly explain the reasons for the request and provide the evidence necessary to support it.

An appeal is distinct from the standard process of responding to reviewers’ comments or submitting revisions requested during the evaluation of a manuscript.

Submitting an appeal does not necessarily result in a change to the original editorial decision. The journal will reassess the arguments presented and communicate the resulting decision to the author.

Corrections to the Scholarly Record

Revista Estrategia Organizacional recognises the importance of preserving the accuracy, integrity and traceability of the published scholarly record.

When errors, omissions, integrity concerns or other circumstances that may affect a published article are identified after publication, the journal will assess the case and determine the most appropriate editorial action according to the nature, severity and potential impact of the issue on the reliability of the published content.

Where appropriate, the journal may publish:

  • a correction;
  • a clarification;
  • an expression of concern;
  • a retraction; or
  • another editorial notice necessary to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

Corrections

A correction may be published when an error or omission requires amendment but does not substantially invalidate the main results, interpretations or conclusions of the article.

The correction should clearly identify the affected article, explain the amendment made and remain permanently linked to the original publication record.

Expressions of Concern

The journal may publish an expression of concern when significant doubts exist regarding the integrity or reliability of an article but sufficient evidence is not yet available to determine whether a correction or retraction is required.

An expression of concern may subsequently be updated when further information becomes available or the relevant investigation has been concluded.

Retractions

Retraction may be considered when there is sufficient evidence that the results or conclusions of an article are unreliable, or when serious issues are identified, including fabrication or falsification of data, substantial plagiarism, redundant publication or other forms of misconduct or breaches that significantly compromise the integrity of the article.

The retraction notice should clearly identify the affected article, state the reasons for the decision and remain publicly available and permanently linked to the original article.

Whenever possible, the retracted article will remain accessible as part of the scholarly record and will be clearly identified as retracted.

Exceptional Removal of Published Content

Complete removal of a published article will be considered only in exceptional circumstances, for example where continued availability may infringe legal or privacy rights, where removal is required by law, or where the content presents a serious risk if it remains publicly available.

Where technically and legally possible, the article metadata and a public notice explaining the removal will be retained to preserve the traceability of the scholarly record.

Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for promptly informing the journal if they identify significant errors or concerns affecting an article after publication.

The journal may request information, documentation or clarification from the authors and, where necessary, consult reviewers, experts, institutions or other relevant parties before reaching a decision.

Editorial decisions concerning corrections, expressions of concern or retractions are the responsibility of the journal and will be guided primarily by the need to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

Relationship with Other Policies

Cases involving plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of information, conflicts of interest, authorship, research ethics or other potential forms of misconduct will be considered in conjunction with the Code of Ethics and Good Practice and the relevant research integrity policies of Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Revista Estrategia Organizacional requires the transparent disclosure and appropriate management of any conflict of interest that could influence, or reasonably be perceived as influencing, the conduct of research, interpretation of results, evaluation of a manuscript or editorial decision-making.

The existence of a conflict of interest does not necessarily imply misconduct, nor does it automatically result in the rejection of a manuscript. Disclosure enables potential influences to be identified and appropriately managed, thereby safeguarding the independence and integrity of the scientific and editorial process.

Conflicts of Interest of Authors

All authors must disclose any relevant financial or non-financial interests related to the work submitted.

Potential conflicts may include, but are not limited to, employment or professional relationships, funding, consultancy activities, financial interests, commercial relationships, personal or institutional relationships, and any other circumstances that could influence, or reasonably be perceived as influencing, the conduct of the research, interpretation of its results or publication.

Where no conflicts of interest exist, authors must explicitly state this.

Relevant information must be provided during the submission process and included within the transparency declarations accompanying the published article.

Funding and Conflicts of Interest

Sources of research funding must be declared separately and transparently, including, where applicable, identification of the funding institution or organisation.

Authors must disclose any role played by funders in the study design, collection or analysis of data, interpretation of results, preparation of the manuscript or decision to submit the work for publication.

Funding does not in itself constitute a conflict of interest. However, any relationship that could affect, or reasonably be perceived as affecting, the independence of the research must be disclosed.

Conflicts of Interest of Reviewers

Reviewers must inform the editorial team of any relationship or circumstance that could compromise, or reasonably be perceived as compromising, the independence and impartiality of their assessment.

Where a conflict could significantly affect the objectivity of the review, the reviewer must decline to evaluate the manuscript.

Editorial Conflicts of Interest

Editors and other members of the editorial team must not participate in decisions concerning manuscripts where a personal, professional, academic, institutional, financial or other relationship could compromise their impartiality.

In such cases, responsibility for handling the manuscript must be assigned to another editor who has no relevant conflict of interest, while maintaining the same editorial criteria and peer-review procedures applicable to other submissions.

Management and Transparency

Conflicts of interest will be assessed according to their nature and relevance. Where necessary, the journal may request additional information or implement measures to safeguard the independence of the editorial process.

Deliberate failure to disclose a relevant conflict of interest may be assessed in accordance with the journal’s Code of Ethics and Good Practice and its research integrity policies.

If a relevant undisclosed conflict of interest is identified after publication, the journal will assess its potential impact on the article and may take appropriate action to correct the scholarly record in accordance with its Complaints, Appeals and Corrections to the Scholarly Record Policy

Research Ethics Policy

Research submitted to Revista Estrategia Organizacional must have been conducted in accordance with recognised ethical principles and with the applicable legal, institutional and regulatory requirements of the country or countries in which the study was carried out.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their research respects the rights, dignity, autonomy, privacy and well-being of participants and that any risks associated with participation have been appropriately considered and minimised.

Research Involving Human Participants

Research involving human participants, whether individually or collectively, must comply with the ethical requirements applicable to the design and conduct of the study.

This includes, where applicable, research involving surveys, interviews, focus groups, interventions, experiments, observations or other procedures through which data are obtained directly from individuals.

Where the nature of the research requires ethical approval, authors must state in the manuscript:

  • the name of the ethics committee, institutional review board or equivalent body that reviewed the study;

  • the corresponding institution;

  • the approval number, code or reference, where available; and

  • any other information necessary to identify the ethical approval obtained.

Ethical approval must have been obtained before the commencement of the research activities for which such approval is required.

Exemption from Ethical Approval

Where formal ethical approval is not required under the applicable regulations or because of the nature of the research, authors must state this and provide an appropriate justification where relevant.

Where a formal exemption has been granted by an ethics committee, institution or other competent body, this should be identified in the manuscript.

The journal may request additional documentation where necessary to verify the ethical conditions under which the research was conducted.

Informed Consent

Where applicable, participation in research must be voluntary and based on an appropriate informed consent process.

Participants should have received sufficient and understandable information about the nature and purpose of the research, the conditions of their participation, the handling of the information they provide and their right not to participate or to withdraw, in accordance with the conditions applicable to the study.

Authors must state in the manuscript that informed consent was obtained whenever it was required.

Where written consent is not possible or is not appropriate to the methodology employed, the alternative procedure used must be explained and, where applicable, its approval by the relevant ethics committee should be reported.

Privacy, Confidentiality and Personal Data

Research involving the collection or use of personal information must implement appropriate measures to protect participants’ privacy, confidentiality and data security.

Personal, sensitive or potentially identifiable data must be handled in accordance with applicable legislation, the ethical approvals obtained and the conditions communicated to participants.

Publication of information that could enable an individual to be identified requires the appropriate authorisation or consent.

Potentially Vulnerable Individuals and Groups

Research involving individuals or groups in potentially vulnerable situations must incorporate safeguards proportionate to the characteristics of the study and the potential risks associated with participation.

Vulnerability should be assessed within the specific context of the research, taking into consideration factors such as age, capacity to provide consent, relationships of dependency or power, social or economic circumstances, and any other conditions that could affect participants’ autonomy or freedom to participate.

Researchers must pay particular attention to ensuring that consent is genuinely voluntary and that participants are protected from coercion, pressure or undue influence.

Research Involving Animals

Where research involves animals, authors must comply with the applicable legislation, institutional requirements and ethical standards governing animal welfare and the responsible use of animals in research.

The manuscript must identify, where applicable, the ethics committee or equivalent body that approved the study and provide the relevant protocol, licence or approval number.

Where formal ethical approval is not required, authors must provide an explanation and identify the ethical or regulatory framework applied.

Ethics and Transparency Statements in Published Articles

Manuscripts must include the ethical information relevant to the nature of the research. Where applicable, this should include information concerning ethics committee approval, informed consent, the handling of personal data and measures taken to protect research participants.

These statements form part of the transparency mechanisms established by Revista Estrategia Organizacional and may be verified during the editorial process.

Where research does not involve human participants, animals or personal data requiring specific ethical considerations, authors may explicitly state this.

Reference Frameworks and Standards

Revista Estrategia Organizacional takes into account internationally recognised principles and good practices in research ethics according to their relevance to the nature and methodology of each study.

The principal reference frameworks include:

The application of these frameworks is complemented by the legal, regulatory and institutional requirements applicable to the location and context in which the research was conducted.

Compliance with Ethical Requirements

The journal may request additional documentation or clarification from authors concerning ethical approval, informed consent, the handling of personal data or other ethical aspects of the research.

Where substantial concerns arise regarding compliance with applicable ethical requirements, the editorial process may be suspended while the matter is assessed.

Manuscripts that do not meet the ethical requirements applicable to the research conducted may not be considered for publication.

Research Misconduct and Publication Integrity Policy

Revista Estrategia Organizacional takes appropriate measures to prevent, identify and address conduct that may compromise the integrity of research, the editorial process or the published scholarly record.

Potential cases of misconduct will be assessed confidentially, impartially and in a documented manner, taking into account the nature of each case and drawing on the recommendations and procedures of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Forms of Misconduct

Research and publication misconduct may occur at different stages of the scientific and editorial process. Situations that may require investigation include, but are not limited to:

  • fabrication, falsification or inappropriate manipulation of data, results, images or other evidence;
  • plagiarism or misappropriation of content;
  • redundant or duplicate publication;
  • citation or reference manipulation;
  • manipulation, interference or fraud in the peer-review process;
  • false or misleading information concerning authorship, identity, institutional affiliation or contributions;
  • failure to disclose relevant conflicts of interest;
  • unauthorised use of copyrighted or third-party material;
  • serious breaches of ethical requirements applicable to the research;
  • submission of false documentation, declarations or information during the editorial process; and
  • any attempt to systematically manipulate the submission, evaluation, acceptance or publication process.

Matters specifically concerning originality, conflicts of interest, research ethics, the use of third-party material or artificial intelligence will also be considered in accordance with the journal’s relevant specific policies.

Identification and Reporting of Potential Misconduct

Potential misconduct may be identified during editorial assessment, peer review or after publication, or may be brought to the journal’s attention by authors, reviewers, readers, institutions or other parties.

Individuals reporting a potential integrity concern should, where possible, provide sufficient information and evidence to enable an initial assessment of the case.

Concerns relating to potential research or publication misconduct may be submitted to the journal’s official email address: revista.ecacen@unad.edu.co.

The journal will consider allegations regardless of whether they are received before or after publication.

Assessment Procedure

When a potential case of misconduct is identified, the journal will conduct a preliminary assessment of the available information to determine the nature and extent of the concerns raised.

Where appropriate, authors or other individuals involved will be given an opportunity to provide explanations, documentation or additional information before an editorial decision is reached.

The journal may seek additional advice or consult relevant specialists where the complexity of the case requires it.

Relevant actions and decisions will be documented to maintain the traceability of the procedure.

Relationship with Institutions and Other Journals

Revista Estrategia Organizacional recognises that formal investigation of certain forms of suspected misconduct may fall within the responsibility of the researchers’ institutions or other bodies with the appropriate authority and capacity to conduct such investigations.

Where warranted by the nature or seriousness of the case, the journal may communicate relevant concerns and available evidence to the appropriate institution or competent authority for further assessment.

Where a potential integrity issue also affects content submitted to or published by other journals, communication with their editorial teams may be undertaken when necessary to clarify the matter and protect the scholarly record.

Such communications will respect confidentiality and will seek to disclose only the information necessary for the appropriate assessment of the case.

Actions during the Editorial Process

Where significant concerns arise regarding the integrity of a manuscript under consideration, the editorial process may be temporarily suspended while the matter is assessed.

Depending on the outcome of the assessment, the journal may request clarification or corrections, continue the editorial process where the concerns have been satisfactorily resolved, or reject the manuscript where there is sufficient evidence of serious breaches of editorial or research integrity requirements.

Actions after Publication

Allegations concerning published articles will be considered regardless of the time elapsed since publication.

Where an investigation or assessment determines that an issue affects the reliability, integrity or transparency of a published article, the journal will take appropriate action to protect the scholarly record.

Depending on the circumstances, such action may include a correction, expression of concern, retraction or other appropriate editorial notice, in accordance with the journal’s Complaints, Appeals and Corrections to the Scholarly Record Policy.

Principles for Handling Allegations

The submission of an allegation does not in itself constitute evidence of misconduct.

The journal will seek to distinguish between honest errors, scientific disagreements and conduct that may compromise research or publication integrity.

Cases will be assessed with due regard to confidentiality, impartiality, proportionality, appropriate documentation and the opportunity for the parties involved to respond.

Editorial decisions will be guided primarily by the need to protect the integrity and reliability of the scholarly record.

Reference Framework

Revista Estrategia Organizacional takes into account the principles, guidelines and procedures developed by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) for addressing potential cases of research misconduct and publication integrity:

https://publicationethics.org/

Where appropriate, the journal will refer to the relevant COPE guidance and flowcharts according to the specific nature of the case.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that any third-party material incorporated into a manuscript may be lawfully used and published by Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Third-party material includes any content for which the authors of the manuscript do not hold the relevant rights. This may include, but is not limited to, text, figures, illustrations, photographs, tables, graphs, datasets, maps, instruments or scales, questionnaires, screenshots, audiovisual content and other previously published or copyright-protected material.

Permissions and Licences

Before submitting a manuscript, authors must determine whether the third-party material they intend to use requires permission from the relevant rights holder.

Where permission is required, it must allow the material to be used within the article and to be published and distributed electronically by the journal. Authors must retain the relevant documentation and provide it to Revista Estrategia Organizacional upon request.

Additional permission is not required where material is made available under a licence that expressly permits the intended use, provided that all conditions of that licence are met.

Where authors consider that the use of particular material is permitted under an applicable legal exception or limitation to copyright, they are responsible for ensuring that the proposed use complies with the relevant requirements.

Attribution of Third-Party Material

All third-party material must be appropriately attributed to its original source and creator, regardless of whether its use requires explicit permission.

Where applicable, the rights holder, original source, relevant licence and any information required under the applicable permission or licence must also be provided.

Obtaining permission to reuse material does not remove the obligation to appropriately cite or acknowledge its source.

Third-Party Material and the Article Licence

The Creative Commons licence applied to an article does not automatically extend to third-party material that is subject to different copyright, licensing or reuse conditions.

Where material included in an article is not covered by the publication’s general licence, this must be clearly indicated alongside the material or in the relevant accompanying information.

Users wishing to reuse such material must comply with the conditions established by the rights holder or the specific licence applicable to that material.

Authors’ Responsibilities

Authors are responsible for obtaining any necessary permissions and for providing complete and accurate information regarding the rights and conditions governing the use of third-party material included in their manuscripts.

Revista Estrategia Organizacional may request evidence of the permissions obtained and may require material to be modified, replaced or removed where sufficient rights for publication cannot be demonstrated.

Submission of a manuscript constitutes confirmation that the authors hold or have obtained the necessary rights and permissions for all third-party material incorporated into the work.

Relationship with Other Policies

General provisions concerning copyright, publication licensing and the conditions governing reuse of published articles are established in the Open Access and Copyright Policy of Revista Estrategia Organizacional.

Cases involving the unauthorised use of protected material may be assessed in accordance with the journal’s Code of Ethics and Good Practice and its Research Misconduct and Publication Integrity Policy.

Policy on the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence

Revista Estrategia Organizacional recognises that artificial intelligence (AI), including generative artificial intelligence and other AI-powered computational tools, forms part of a rapidly evolving scientific and editorial environment and may legitimately contribute to the development, analysis, communication and dissemination of research.

The journal does not prohibit the use of artificial intelligence. Its policy is based on the principles of human responsibility, transparency, traceability, research integrity, protection of confidential information and reproducibility, where applicable.

The appropriateness of using an AI tool depends on its purpose, the disciplinary context and the extent to which its use may influence the research process or the scientific content being communicated.

Human Responsibility and Authorship

Artificial intelligence tools and systems cannot be considered authors or co-authors of an article.

Authorship entails intellectual responsibility and the capacity to be accountable for the accuracy, originality, integrity and content of the research. These responsibilities can only be assumed by human authors.

Regardless of the level of assistance provided by an AI tool, authors remain fully responsible for all submitted and published content, including text, data, analyses, interpretations, references, tables, figures, images, conclusions and other elements of the work.

The use of AI does not transfer or reduce authors’ responsibility for the scientific content of their work.

Use of AI in Conducting Research

Artificial intelligence may be used as a tool within the research process when its use is scientifically appropriate and consistent with the ethical, methodological and legal principles applicable to the study.

Depending on the nature of the research, this may include applications related to data generation or processing, programming, classification, modelling, quantitative or qualitative analysis, pattern recognition, validation, visualisation, automation of procedures or other scientific functions.

AI systems, models, content, data or outputs may also be studied directly when they constitute the object of the research.

Where the use of AI forms part of the methodology or may influence the data, analyses, results or reproducibility of the study, its use must be adequately described in the methodology section of the article.

The description should identify, as appropriate, the tool or system used, its function within the research and the manner in which it contributed to the procedure. Where relevant to understanding or reproducing the study, additional information should be provided, such as the model, version, date of access or use, relevant parameters, instructions or prompts, and procedures for validation or human oversight.

The level of information required should be proportionate to the significance of the tool within the scientific process.

Use of AI in Scientific Writing, Editing and Communication

Authors may use artificial intelligence tools to assist with drafting, revising, translating, summarising, reorganising, editing or improving the clarity and linguistic expression of a manuscript.

The use of these tools does not replace the intellectual judgement of the authors or alter their responsibility for the submitted content.

Authors must critically review any content produced or modified using AI and verify its accuracy, coherence, relevance and correspondence with the research actually conducted.

Routine use of automated tools for functions such as spelling or grammar correction, formatting, reference management or equivalent technical functions does not require a specific declaration.

Where generative artificial intelligence is used substantively to produce, reformulate, translate, synthesise or structure content incorporated into the manuscript, authors must transparently declare its use and purpose.

Accuracy, Sources and References

Authors must independently verify any information obtained or generated through artificial intelligence tools before incorporating it into a manuscript.

AI tools must not be used as substitutes for original scholarly sources where those sources can be identified and consulted.

All references must be verified by the authors against the corresponding sources. References that are non-existent, inaccurate, fabricated or whose existence and content have not been verified must not be included.

Authors must also ensure that any content generated or transformed using AI complies with applicable requirements concerning attribution, intellectual property and the use of third-party material.

Data, Privacy and Confidentiality

Authors must consider the privacy, storage, processing and reuse conditions associated with the AI tools they use.

Personal, sensitive, confidential, restricted or third-party information must not be entered into AI systems where sufficient authorisation has not been obtained or where the conditions of the tool do not ensure processing compatible with applicable ethical, legal and institutional requirements.

Where the use of AI forms part of research involving participant data, authors must also comply with the journal’s Research Ethics Policy.

AI-Generated Images, Figures and Other Content

The scientific use of images, figures, visualisations, audio, video or other materials generated or modified using artificial intelligence must be disclosed where the involvement of the tool is relevant to understanding how the content was produced.

Where such materials constitute data, results, objects of study or methodological components of the research, their generation and processing must be described in sufficient detail to allow appropriate interpretation.

Artificial intelligence must not be used to fabricate, falsify, deceptively alter or present as scientific evidence content that does not correspond to the research process actually conducted.

Declaration of Artificial Intelligence Use

Revista Estrategia Organizacional incorporates disclosure of artificial intelligence use within its editorial transparency mechanisms.

Where disclosure is required, authors must provide sufficient information to identify the tool or system used and the purpose for which it was employed.

Where AI has directly contributed to the methodology, generation or processing of data, analysis, validation or production of results, the relevant information must also be reported in the methodology section of the article.

Authors may also expressly declare that no declarable artificial intelligence tools were used.

Artificial Intelligence and Peer Review

Manuscripts submitted for evaluation are confidential documents.

Reviewers must not upload, enter or share complete manuscripts, substantial portions of manuscripts, unpublished data or other confidential information with artificial intelligence systems where the privacy, storage or reuse conditions of the tool do not ensure the confidentiality of the content.

Where an AI tool is permissibly used to assist with an evaluation, the reviewer remains fully responsible for their observations, analysis and editorial recommendation and must inform the journal where AI has contributed substantively to the review report.

Artificial intelligence does not replace the expert judgement of the reviewer.

Use of Artificial Intelligence in Editorial Processes

Revista Estrategia Organizacional may use AI-powered tools to support specific editorial, technical or quality-control activities, provided that such use remains under human oversight and respects confidentiality, data protection, intellectual property and the integrity of the editorial process.

Automated tools may support editorial processes but must not replace editorial responsibility or human decision-making regarding the acceptance or rejection of a manuscript.

Where the journal’s use of AI systems may substantially affect the evaluation of a manuscript or involve the processing of confidential content through external services, appropriate measures must be taken to ensure transparency and protection of information.

Principle of Proportionality and Technological Evolution

The journal will apply this policy proportionately to the function and impact of artificial intelligence in each research context.

Not all uses of AI require the same level of disclosure. A tool used for a minor technical function will not be treated in the same manner as a system involved in data generation, analysis, interpretation or the substantive production of scientific content.

Evaluation will focus on preserving the transparency of the scientific process and human responsibility rather than penalising the legitimate use of a technology solely because it has been used.

Given the rapid evolution of artificial intelligence and the international standards governing its use in research and scholarly publishing, this policy will be reviewed periodically and may be updated to incorporate new technological, ethical, legal and editorial developments.

Reference Frameworks

Revista Estrategia Organizacional draws on international principles and good practices concerning the responsible use of artificial intelligence in research and scholarly publishing, including:

  • Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
  • International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) recommendations concerning artificial intelligence in scholarly publishing
  • Declaration of Heredia on the use of artificial intelligence in scientific publishing

These frameworks are applied in conjunction with the journal’s policies on research ethics, publication integrity, authorship, privacy, intellectual property and data protection, as well as any applicable legal and institutional requirements.