Revista Estrategia Organizacional is committed to integrity, transparency and accountability throughout all stages of scholarly communication. Its editorial practices are informed by the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and by internationally recognised standards of research ethics and integrity.
The journal implements these principles through specific policies and procedures applicable to authors, reviewers, editors and all other participants in the editorial process. Reference to COPE provides a framework for good practice and does not replace the responsibilities and procedures expressly established by Revista Estrategia Organizacional.
Principles of editorial integrity
Editorial decisions are based on scientific quality, originality, methodological rigour, relevance, clarity and the extent to which a manuscript is consistent with the journal’s focus and scope. Decisions shall not be influenced by an author’s nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, geographical origin, academic position, beliefs or any other personal characteristic.
The journal is committed to:
-
preserving the independence and integrity of editorial decision-making;
-
ensuring objective, confidential and impartial scholarly evaluation;
-
identifying and appropriately managing conflicts of interest;
-
protecting the confidentiality of manuscripts and information obtained during their evaluation;
-
preventing and responding to plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, inappropriate image manipulation, redundant publication, citation manipulation, inappropriate authorship and other forms of research or publication misconduct;
-
maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record through corrections, clarifications, expressions of concern or retractions when required;
-
providing procedures for handling complaints, appeals and allegations relating to the editorial process;
-
promoting the ethical treatment of human participants and animals and the responsible protection of personal data;
-
promoting transparency regarding funding, author contributions, conflicts of interest, data availability and the use of artificial intelligence tools.
Cases of suspected misconduct will be examined in a documented, confidential and proportionate manner, in accordance with the journal’s policies and, where appropriate, the procedures and flowcharts recommended by COPE. The journal may request additional information or documentation from authors, reviewers or institutions when necessary to clarify a case.
Responsibilities of editors
The editorial team is responsible for safeguarding the integrity of the editorial process and the scientific content published by the journal.
Editors shall:
-
assess manuscripts exclusively on academic and editorial grounds;
-
ensure the consistent application of the journal’s established peer-review process;
-
select reviewers with appropriate expertise and seek to avoid relationships or interests that could compromise the independence of the review;
-
maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts, reviews and editorial communications;
-
disclose and appropriately manage any conflict of interest that could affect an editorial decision;
-
refrain from participating in decisions concerning manuscripts where a conflict could compromise their impartiality;
-
ensure that manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial team, Editorial Board or individuals otherwise associated with the journal are subject to the same scientific standards and an independent review process;
-
investigate allegations or indications of possible misconduct diligently;
-
provide mechanisms through which authors may submit complaints or appeals;
-
preserve the integrity of the published record by taking appropriate editorial action when errors or concerns are identified after publication.
Decisions to accept or reject manuscripts shall be based on their scholarly assessment, scientific contribution and alignment with the journal’s focus and scope. An acceptance decision may be reconsidered if serious concerns relating to integrity, ethics, originality or scientific validity are subsequently identified.
Responsibilities of authors
Authors are responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity and transparency of the work they submit and publish.
When submitting a manuscript to Revista Estrategia Organizacional, authors shall:
-
submit original work that does not involve plagiarism, fabrication, falsification or inappropriate manipulation of information, data, images, results or references;
-
avoid simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to more than one journal and redundant or substantially duplicate publication;
-
appropriately acknowledge and cite the ideas, data, methods and work of others;
-
ensure that all individuals listed as authors have made a substantial contribution to the work and that no individual who meets the criteria for authorship has been unjustifiably excluded;
-
transparently describe the contributions made by each author;
-
disclose sources of funding and any personal, professional, institutional or financial relationship that could constitute a conflict of interest;
-
provide accurate information about the methods, data and procedures used and, where appropriate, retain the documentation necessary to support the research;
-
obtain all ethical approvals, permissions and consents required for the research;
-
protect the privacy, confidentiality and rights of participants;
-
obtain the necessary permissions for the use of third-party copyrighted material;
-
promptly notify the journal of any significant error identified after submission or publication;
-
transparently disclose the use of artificial intelligence tools where required by the journal’s policy.
Authorship entails responsibility for the scientific content of the publication. Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors and cannot assume responsibility for a manuscript.
Mandatory ethics and transparency statements
As part of its mechanisms for editorial transparency, Revista Estrategia Organizacional requires all published articles to include a Disclosure Box (Declaraciones y transparencia del artículo). This is a mandatory component of the published article and must be completed in accordance with the nature of the research.
Where applicable, the Disclosure Box shall provide information on acknowledgements, author contributions, funding sources, conflicts of interest, ethical approval for research involving human participants or animals, informed consent and privacy protection, data-related restrictions, and the use of artificial intelligence technologies or AI-assisted tools.
Where ethical approval is required, authors must identify the responsible committee or institution and provide the relevant approval number, protocol or other verifiable information. Where a particular declaration does not apply, this must be expressly indicated when required by the journal’s established format.
Information provided in these statements must be accurate and consistent with the content of the article. Deliberate omission or provision of false information may be considered an integrity concern and handled in accordance with the journal’s policies.
Responsibilities of reviewers
Reviewers play an essential role in safeguarding the quality and scientific integrity of the work published by the journal.
Reviewers shall:
-
accept only assignments for which they possess sufficient academic expertise;
-
disclose any actual, potential or perceived conflict of interest before accepting a review;
-
provide objective, reasoned and respectful assessments based on scientific criteria;
-
maintain strict confidentiality regarding the manuscript and any information obtained through the review process;
-
refrain from using ideas, data, methods or results contained in unpublished manuscripts for their own benefit or that of third parties;
-
notify the editorial team if they identify possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, ethical concerns or other irregularities;
-
meet agreed review deadlines or promptly inform the journal if they are unable to complete the review.
Reviewers must not use artificial intelligence tools in ways that compromise the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts, data, personal information or intellectual property. Any permitted use of such technologies must comply with the journal’s Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence.
Research involving humans, animals and personal data
Research involving human participants, animals, personal information or sensitive data must comply with applicable ethical, institutional and legal requirements.
For research involving human participants, authors must report, where applicable, approval by the relevant ethics committee, informed consent and the measures adopted to protect participants’ privacy, confidentiality and rights. Relevant research must observe the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki or equivalent ethical standards applicable to the type of research undertaken.
For research involving animals, authors must identify the relevant institutional approvals and comply with applicable standards for animal welfare and responsible reporting.
Specific requirements are established in the journal’s Policy on Experimentation and Research Ethics and must, where applicable, be reflected in the transparency statements published with the article.
Artificial intelligence and research integrity
Revista Estrategia Organizacional recognises that artificial intelligence technologies may be used as supporting tools in certain research, writing and editorial activities, provided that their use respects the principles of transparency, human accountability, confidentiality, intellectual property and research integrity.
The journal takes as a reference the principles of transparency and responsible use promoted by the Heredia Declaration on the use of artificial intelligence in academic research.
Authors retain full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, references, data, arguments, interpretations and all other content of their manuscripts, regardless of the technological tools used. Artificial intelligence must not be used to fabricate or falsify data, results, images, sources or references, or to conceal practices that contravene research integrity.
Specific disclosure requirements, permitted uses and restrictions applicable to authors, reviewers and editors are established in the journal’s Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence.
Corrections, retractions and integrity of the scholarly record
The journal’s responsibility for research integrity continues after publication.
Where errors or significant concerns are identified in a published article, the journal will assess the nature and seriousness of the issue and may, as appropriate, issue a correction, clarification, expression of concern or retraction.
Allegations of possible misconduct will be considered regardless of when they are received. Actions taken will seek to preserve the transparency and integrity of the scholarly record and will be implemented in accordance with the journal’s policies on complaints and corrections and on misconduct.
Framework and complementary policies
This Code constitutes the general framework for publication ethics and editorial integrity of Revista Estrategia Organizacional and is complemented by the journal’s specific policies on open access and copyright, plagiarism, digital preservation, conflicts of interest, experimentation and research ethics, misconduct, complaints and corrections, use of third-party material, and artificial intelligence.
The journal takes into account the recommendations and resources of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), together with other internationally recognised standards applicable to research ethics, transparency and scholarly publishing. These frameworks are applied in conjunction with the specific policies and editorial procedures established by Revista Estrategia Organizacional.